The biggest Thanksgiving eating mistake I see has nothing to do with pie. It is skipping breakfast to save up calories, then arriving at the table starving. These pumpkin pie overnight oats are the fix: you make them Wednesday night, and Thursday morning they are waiting in the fridge.
Each jar has 20 grams of protein and about 391 calories, calculated from the actual ingredients. That is the Greek yogurt and chia doing their jobs, and it is enough to keep you steady until the turkey comes out.
If you are not sure what a good protein target looks like for your body, my free protein calculator gives you a daily number in about thirty seconds. Then you can see how far one jar gets you.
- 20 grams of protein per jar, with about 391 calories, from Greek yogurt, oats, and chia
- 10 minutes of work Wednesday night, no cooking, four jars ready for four mornings
- The one technique that matters: whisk the wet ingredients smooth before the oats go in, or you get lumps of yogurt and dry pockets of oats
- Keeps 4 days in the fridge; freeze extra jars for up to a month if you want more
- Honest caveat: this tastes like pumpkin pie the way spiced oatmeal tastes like pumpkin pie. It is creamy, warm-spiced, and lightly sweet, not dessert. On Thanksgiving morning that is exactly what you want
Why This Recipe Works
A breakfast with real protein changes how the rest of Thanksgiving goes. When you show up to a big meal with a steady blood sugar and a full stomach, you serve yourself a normal plate. When you show up empty, you eat fast, you eat more, and you feel it by three o’clock.
Protein at breakfast matters more as you get older. Your body gets less efficient at using it to maintain muscle, so spreading it across the day, including the first meal, helps. A jar with 20 grams is a real contribution, not a token amount.
There is also the practical side. Thursday morning is busy. The oven is claimed, the counter is covered, and nobody is standing at the stove making eggs. A jar you can eat with one hand while the turkey brines is the breakfast that actually happens.
A Few Notes on the Ingredients
Rolled oats are the right cut here. Quick oats turn to paste overnight and steel-cut stay chewy and raw-tasting without cooking. Old-fashioned rolled oats soften to a creamy texture and still have a little bite.
Canned pumpkin means plain pumpkin puree, not pumpkin pie filling, which already has sugar and spices added. Half of a standard 15-ounce can goes into this batch; the other half is exactly what my pumpkin protein muffins need, so make both the same week.
Greek yogurt at nonfat gives the most protein per cup and disappears into the oats. If you prefer 2% for the richer texture, use it; the protein number drops by about a gram per jar and the calories go up a little.
Chia seeds thicken the jars and add fiber. Two tablespoons for the whole batch is enough to set the texture without making it gel-like. Skip them and the oats will still work, just a little looser.
Tools I Use for Overnight Oats
Glass containers make it easy to prep a few jars at once, and a food scale keeps the portions honest. Here is what I recommend. (As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
Pumpkin Pie Overnight Oats
Ingredients
Method
- In a large bowl, whisk together the canned pumpkin, Greek yogurt, milk, maple syrup, pumpkin pie spice, vanilla, and salt until smooth with no streaks of yogurt.
- Stir in the rolled oats and chia seeds. Make sure every oat is coated; the mixture will look loose, and that is correct. The oats and chia will soak it up overnight.
- Divide evenly among four jars or containers with lids, about 1.25 cups each. Press the surface flat with the back of a spoon.
- Cover and refrigerate at least 6 hours, and ideally overnight. The oats are ready when they are soft all the way through and the mixture holds its shape on a spoon.
- In the morning, stir once. If a jar is thicker than you like, add a splash of milk. Chop the pecans and scatter a tablespoon over each jar right before eating.
Nutrition
Notes
Made this recipe?
Tap a star below to rate it. A written review is optional, but I read every one.
Plan your week
What Do I Eat This Week? Meal Plan Builder
Turn my recipes into a 7-day plan that fits your calories and protein, with your grocery list added up by store aisle. High-protein, Mediterranean, keto or GLP-1-friendly portions, with gluten-free and dairy-free filters. Swap, lock and print your week.
Build my week →Make It Your Own
- Lower carb: cut the oats to 1.5 cups and add 2 more tablespoons of chia. The jars come out thicker and a little smaller; drop the maple syrup to 2 tablespoons.
- Protein boost: whisk one scoop of vanilla protein powder into the wet ingredients and add a quarter cup more milk. That adds roughly 5 to 6 grams per jar.
- Dairy-free: use a thick unsweetened almond or soy yogurt and your favorite plant milk. Soy keeps the protein closest to the original.
- Less sweet: leave out the maple syrup entirely and stir in a mashed half banana per batch, or nothing at all. The pumpkin and spice carry more than you expect.
- Warm version: scoop a jar into a bowl and microwave 60 to 90 seconds with a splash of milk. It turns into pumpkin oatmeal and smells like a bakery.
Storage, Leftovers, and Serving
Make the whole batch Wednesday night and it carries you through Sunday. The jars keep 4 days in the fridge, and the texture is best on days one through three. By day four they are thicker and want a splash of milk.
Hungry again by 10 a.m.? Start with breakfast. No powder needed.
7 high-protein breakfasts with 17 to 31 g of protein each, calculated nutrition, and a Sunday prep plan that makes weekday mornings a 90-second job. From a NASM-certified coach with more than 20 years of results.
- 7 recipes, real numbers
- No protein powder
- Free, straight to your inbox
Want to see what's inside first? See the free breakfast guide
They freeze, too. Fill the jars an inch short of the top, lid them, and freeze for up to a month. Move a jar to the fridge the night before you want it, and stir in the morning. Add the pecans fresh, never before freezing.
This is the breakfast in my Healthy Thanksgiving Guide, which walks through the whole day, from the morning plan to the plate to the leftovers. The rest of the holiday recipes in the series are there too.
Where I shop
Where I Buy My Pantry Staples
Thrive Market is the online grocery membership I use for pantry staples. It is handy for the oils, nuts, seeds, spices and gluten-free basics that recipes like this one call for, delivered to your door.
Get 40% off your first order →Referral link: new members get 40% off their first order (up to $30), and Thrive Market gives me store credit if you join. I only recommend products I use myself or recommend to my clients.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why Are My Overnight Oats Mushy?
Almost always it is the wrong oats. Quick oats or instant oats are rolled thinner and break down into paste overnight. Use old-fashioned rolled oats and keep the soak to 6 to 12 hours. If they still seem soft, use a little less milk next time; the pumpkin and yogurt already add a lot of moisture.
Can I Make Pumpkin Overnight Oats Without Greek Yogurt?
Yes. Use an extra three-quarter cup of milk in its place and add one more tablespoon of chia to keep the texture thick. The jars will still taste right, but the protein drops by close to half, so the numbers on the card apply only to the Greek yogurt version. Cottage cheese blended smooth is another swap that keeps the protein high.
Are Pumpkin Pie Overnight Oats Healthy?
Each jar comes to about 391 calories with 20 grams of protein, 9 grams of fiber, and 19 grams of sugar, calculated from the listed ingredients. A good share of that sugar is the natural kind in milk and yogurt, and the rest is the maple syrup, which you can cut. As a breakfast that keeps you full for four hours, that is a good trade.
Free printable checklist
The Healthy Thanksgiving Prep Checklist
A day-by-day make-ahead plan: what to cook the weekend before, Wednesday’s big prep, Thursday’s oven order and the day-after plan.
Get the free checklistYour This-Week Plan
Make one batch this Sunday night and eat the jars Monday through Thursday. You will find out how sweet you like them and how thick, and you will have the recipe dialed in before the holiday week. If you want six more breakfasts like this one with the numbers already worked out, grab my free guide, 7 High-Protein Breakfasts That Keep You Full Until Lunch.
This article is for general education and isn’t medical or nutrition advice. Nutrition values are calculated from the listed ingredients and will vary with brands and substitutions. If you have a health condition, food allergy, or take medication, please check with your doctor or a registered dietitian before changing how you eat.
Practical, no-gimmick tips on healthy aging, hormones, fitness and nutrition.
- One email a week, no spam
- Real tips on aging, hormones, fitness and food
- Unsubscribe anytime
Free. I never share your email.
Affiliate links — I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
- 1
Organic Super GreensSpirulina, chlorella & organic superfoods in one scoop — for the days your plate isn’t perfect.
See Super Greens review →Check price - 2
Organic Super RedsBeets, berries & polyphenols for circulation and stamina — the other half of your greens.
See Super Reds review →Check price - 3
Complete Plant-Based ProteinHit your protein without a chalky shake. Mixes clean in smoothies, oats or water.
See Plant Protein review →Check price
Show 4 more picks ↓
- 4
Organic FiberMost people get half the fiber they need. Fills you up and keeps blood sugar steady.
See Fiber review →Check price - 5
Probiotic Gut SupportBetter digestion and less bloat, so you get more out of the food you eat.
See Probiotic review →Check price - 6
Organic D3-K2 2000Two nutrients most of us run short on — immunity, mood and bone support.
See D3-K2 review →Check price - 7
Organic CoffeeOrganic mushroom coffee with six adaptogens. Same cup, better ingredients.
See Coffee review →Check price
Not sure which one fits you? Take my quick Supplement Match →
These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Talk with your doctor before starting a new supplement.
